Introduction
In the world of executive search and recruitment, two primary models dominate the landscape: retained search and contingency search. Both models have their unique advantages and potential drawbacks, and the choice between the two often boils down to the specific needs and circumstances of the hiring organization. However, one factor that can significantly influence this decision is cost. In this blog post, we will delve into the financial implications of retained search versus contingency search, providing a comprehensive comparison to help you make an informed decision.
Understanding the Basics
Before we dive into the financial aspects, it’s crucial to understand what these two models entail.
Retained Search
Retained search firms are hired by organizations to fill a specific position and are paid a retainer fee upfront. They work exclusively on the job until it is filled, providing a dedicated, comprehensive search. This model is typically used for senior-level positions, where the stakes are high, and the right candidate can significantly impact the organization’s success.
Contingency Search
Contingency search firms, on the other hand, only get paid if they successfully fill the position. They often compete with other firms and the company’s internal recruitment efforts. This model is typically used for mid-level positions and below, where the urgency or impact of the hire may not justify the cost of a retained search.
The Financial Implications
Now that we understand the basics, let’s delve into the financial implications of these two models.
Retained Search: The Cost Breakdown
Retained search firms typically charge a fee that is a percentage of the successful candidate’s first-year compensation. This fee is usually around 30-35%. The fee is divided into thirds: one-third is paid upfront, another third is paid after a certain period (usually 30-60 days), and the final third is paid when the candidate is placed.
For example, if you’re hiring for a position with a $200,000 annual salary, a retained search could cost you around $60,000 to $70,000. This cost covers the dedicated time and resources the firm will invest in your search, including market research, candidate sourcing, interviewing, and negotiation.
Contingency Search: The Cost Breakdown
Search firms also typically charge a fee based on the successful candidate’s first-year compensation, often around 20-25%. However, this fee is only paid once the candidate is successfully placed and begins work.
Using the same example of a $200,000 annual salary, a contingency search could cost you around $40,000 to $50,000. This cost reflects the risk the firm takes by investing time and resources into your search without any guaranteed payment.
Comparing the Costs: Retained vs. Contingency
At first glance, it might seem like a cost-effective option. However, the true cost of a search isn’t just about the fee. It’s also about the value you get for your money and the potential costs of a bad hire or a prolonged search.
Value for Money
Executive search firms provide a dedicated, comprehensive service. They invest significant time and resources into understanding your organization and its needs, sourcing and vetting candidates, and ensuring a good fit. They also provide a guarantee period, during which they will conduct a new search at no additional cost if the placed candidate leaves or is terminated.
Executive search firms, due to their payment structure, may not be able to invest the same level of resources into your search. They may also be less likely to provide a guarantee period, or it may be shorter than that offered by retained search firms.
Cost of a Bad Hire
A bad hire can be costly, both financially and in terms of lost productivity and potential damage to your organization’s reputation. The U.S. Department of Labor estimates that a bad hire can cost up to 30% of the employee’s first-year earnings. For a $200,000 position, that’s a potential cost of $60,000.
Retained search firms, with their comprehensive vetting process and guarantee period, can significantly reduce the risk of a bad hire. While contingency firms also strive to place the right candidate, their resources and guarantees may not be as extensive.
Cost of a Prolonged Search
A prolonged search can also be costly. Every day a position remains unfilled, your organization loses potential productivity. If other employees have to pick up the slack, it can also lead to burnout and decreased morale.
Retained search firms, with their dedicated service, can often fill positions more quickly than contingency firms. However, this is not always the case, and the speed of a search can also depend on factors like the attractiveness of the position and the state of the job market.
Making the Right Choice for Your Organization
When comparing the financial implications of retained search versus contingency search, it’s essential to consider not just the fee, but also the value for money and the potential costs of a bad hire or a prolonged search.
Retained search can be a worthwhile investment for senior-level positions, where the stakes are high, and the right candidate can significantly impact your organization’s success. It can also be a good choice if you need to fill a position quickly, or if you value a comprehensive, dedicated service and a longer guarantee period.
Contingency search can be a more cost-effective option for mid-level positions and below, where the urgency or impact of the hire may not justify the cost of a retained search. It can also be a good choice if you’re comfortable with a less comprehensive service and a shorter guarantee period, or if you want to keep your options open by working with multiple firms.
Conclusion
In the end, the choice between retained search and contingency search is a strategic decision that should be based on your organization’s specific needs and circumstances. By understanding the financial implications of these two models, you can make a more informed decision that will help you attract and retain the right talent for your organization.
PS: Looking for exceptional leadership? With over 17 years of experience, Salmela Talent excels in finding leaders who align with your organization’s unique vision. Our distinctive approach focuses on your story, ensuring a perfect fit. Let’s co-author your success story. Book a call today!
